Tech • IA • Crypto
Brian Cox I Would Never Go to Mars #briancox #mars
TL;DR
Traveling to Mars remains vastly more difficult and risky than lunar missions, with major technical and human challenges still unresolved.
KEY POINTS
Mars Missions Far More Complex Than Lunar Travel
Reaching Mars is described as significantly harder than returning to the Moon, which itself has proven challenging decades after the Apollo era. While lunar missions take only a few days, a Mars journey requires months of travel each way, with total mission durations approaching or exceeding a year. This extended timeline introduces logistical, technical, and human risks far beyond previous space exploration efforts.
Apollo Program Set an Exceptionally High Benchmark
The success of the late-1960s Apollo missions is characterized as one of humanity’s greatest achievements, involving hundreds of thousands of engineers and consuming a substantial share of U.S. GDP at the time. Replicating even part of that success today has proven difficult, as seen with delays and challenges in the Artemis program, which aims to return humans to the Moon.
Distance From Earth Creates Critical Risks
A key distinction between current space missions and a Mars journey is distance. The International Space Station orbits roughly 100 miles above Earth, allowing relatively quick emergency returns. By contrast, astronauts en route to Mars would be effectively unreachable once they depart, with no possibility of rapid evacuation or resupply. Any medical or technical emergency would have to be managed entirely in isolation.
Human Endurance Limits Still Uncertain
Although astronauts have spent extended periods aboard the ISS, those missions occur in close proximity to Earth. A Mars mission would test human endurance in ways not yet fully understood, including prolonged exposure to microgravity, radiation, and psychological stress from extreme isolation. Current knowledge is insufficient to guarantee crew safety over such long durations.
Limited Mission Flexibility
Once a spacecraft departs for Mars, mission flexibility is minimal. Crews would be committed to completing a full trajectory, typically involving orbiting Mars and waiting for the correct alignment to return to Earth. This lack of flexibility significantly increases mission risk compared to shorter, more adaptable lunar operations.
Reluctance Among Experts to Personally Attempt Mars Travel
Despite enthusiasm for space exploration, some experts express hesitation about personally undertaking a Mars mission. A lunar flyby—such as witnessing the iconic “Earthrise” view first captured in 1968—is considered appealing, but Mars is seen as too risky under current conditions. The absence of infrastructure, such as reliable habitats or emergency support systems, reinforces this reluctance.
Future Space Tourism Seen as Plausible
While Mars remains a distant goal, space travel more broadly could become accessible within the next century. Advances in technology may enable civilians, particularly younger generations today, to experience space travel as a form of high-cost tourism. Trips to low Earth orbit or even the Moon are viewed as potentially achievable for private individuals willing to pay.
Infrastructure Needed Before Mars Becomes Viable
Long-term habitation on Mars would require significant infrastructure, including habitats, life-support systems, and possibly commercial facilities. Without these developments, human missions remain high-risk exploratory endeavors rather than sustainable or repeatable operations.
CONCLUSION
Human missions to Mars face profound technical, medical, and logistical hurdles that far exceed those of lunar travel, making routine journeys unlikely in the near future despite growing ambitions in space exploration.
Full transcript
Most people dream about going to Mars, but when a physicist was asked if he'd actually go, his answer surprised everyone. >> Elon Musk like wants to take us to Mars. Firstly, how hard will that be for us to achieve? >> Really hard. Um, it's so we're seeing now it's quite hard to go back to the moon, right? I mean, it was it was one of the one of one of I think the great achievements in human history that we got to the moon in the late60s. >> Apollo was astonishing. Um it was but it was huge. I mean it's hundreds of thousands of engineers quite a large percentage of US GDP. Really hard to do and it was wonderful. So now we're going back with Artimus but that's proving difficult. >> Yeah, >> we'll get there in the next few years. Right. We'll we'll land on the moon again. But it's so different. It's a couple of days to fly to the moon. >> It's months to fly to Mars. It's the best part of a year. >> Oh man. So, so you're away for more than a year, right? As as an astronaut, we don't really know how to do that. We've had astronauts on the space station. >> Yeah. >> But that's minutes away from the Earth, is it? >> So, we saw, you know, that there was a on the last mission there was a medical incident and and they came back. Yeah. >> So, you're not far you're you're less than flying from London to New York, right? You in principle, you come out of the space station, it's only 100 miles or so up, right? Less. But Mars, you are once you're gone, you're gone. So once you fly off, you all that you can do is go around Mars and come back again. And it's months and months and months and months and months. So we don't really know how to do that. >> You know, we So I think it's really difficult. >> Is it an ambition of yours to go to space at any point in your lifetime? >> I'd love to see Earthrise, you know, the famous Apollo 8 picture which was taken on my first Christmas Eve, actually. Wow. Christmas Eve 1968. And I met Jim Levelvel who was the commander of that mission and it was one of the great moments of my life actually talking to him because he's a hero of mine >> and he was on Apollo 13 as well remarkable astronaut >> but I'd love to see that. So I wouldn't mind slinging around the moon seeing the earth rise coming back again. No way would I go to Mars >> until they built some hotels and things you know restaurants and whatever. I I'm not going >> do you think horrendous that >> is in the next sort of century a realistic thing of you know >> 100 years I mean certainly in space and I would think on the moon that we know to do that it's relatively easy given what we know now so I would think I'm sure that anyone's listening to this who's >> you know I don't know in their teens maybe yeah they're going to get the chance to go into space if they want. >> Wow. It might be quite an expensive holiday, but it's going to be like going on safari, right? One of those things you could save up probably. You could probably do it, I think. I'm sure. Actually, >> be a bit silly, but >> even the moon, maybe. Even the moon. Maybe you could do